Publication Awards

The Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society’s Publications Awards are given out for the best publications dealing with the history of Northwestern Ontario.

They fall into six categories:

  • M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: full-length scholarly works
  • J.P. Bertrand Award: scholarly articles
  • Gertrude H. Dyke Award: full-length popular works
  • George B. Macgillivray Award: popular articles
  • Ernest R. Zimmermann: First Publication Award
  • Innovative Media Award for the History of Northwestern Ontario: non-traditional and emerging public history formats

To learn more about the individuals these awards and who they are named after, click here.

A great many excellent books and articles, both popular and scholarly, are written about the history of our region each year, yet many of their authors struggle for recognition. These awards are intended to help publicize such works, to recognize the excellence of local writers, and to encourage new authors to write about our history. The awards are made by independent panels of judges in each category.

Future Awards

Nominations are open for the next Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Publications Awards program. Books and articles must have been published within the past three years to qualify.

Nominations can be submitted to: [email protected] or 425 Donald Street East, Thunder Bay, Ont. P7E 5V1

Previous Award Winners

To edit this section, duplicate the top panel and then update just the information in the bullets:

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • No Nominations

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • No Nominations

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Nigro, Laura, Lori Chambers, and Michel S. Beaulieu. “Women Not Welcome: Martinie v. the Italian Society of Port Arthur.” In Essays in the History of Canadian Law Volume XII: New Perspectives on Gender and the Law, edited by Lori Chambers and Joan Sangster, 275-303. Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History and the University of Toronto Press, 2023.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Lorenowich, Sarah. “Grains of History: Preserving Stories of Thunder Bay’s Waterfront,” Lake Superior Magazine, August 2024

Ernest R. Zimmermann Award: (First Publication)

  • Omelijaniuk, Christopher. “Combatting the “Black Bird”: Competition between the Hudson’s Bay Company and the American Fur Compan.” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records 2024)

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Scott Berthelette. Heirs of an Ambivalent Empire: French-Indigenous Relations and the Rise of the Metis in the Hudson Bay Watershed. Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2022.

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • No Nominations

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Tom Peotto and Connie Nelson, “Food Production in the Wabigoon Basin: The First Nine Thousand Years.” The Canadian Historical Review 103, no. 4 (2022), 563-589.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Hanna Johnson, “Swedish Immigrants and Religion in Port Arthur and Fort William, 1883-1914.” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records L (2022), 23-36.

Ernest R. Zimmermann Award: (First Publication)

  • Hanna Johnson, “Swedish Immigrants and Religion in Port Arthur and Fort William, 1883-1914.” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records L (2022), 23-36.

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Benidickson, Jamie. Levelling the Lake: Transboundary Resource Management in the Lake of the Woods Watershed. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2019.

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • Skrepichuk, William P. Troop Treks of 1885: Documents and Illustrations (Thunder Bay: Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, 2019.

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Raffo, Peter. “Saul Laskin and the Making of Thunder Bay.” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records XLVIII (2020): 5-39.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Lavoie, Edgar J. Pioneering a Great Circle Route in Northern Ontario: Von Grounau’s ‘Greenland Whale’ Overnight in Longlac,: Thunder Bay Papers and Records (XLVII, 2019), 76-85.

Ernest R. Zimmermann Award: (First Publication)

  • Johnsen, Greg. “’Bats and Balls Have Been Sent For’: The Beginnings of Baseball in Thunder Bay, 1875-1889.” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records XLVII (2019): 86-106.

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Beaulieu, Michel S., Ratz, David K., Tronrud, Thorold J. and Kirker, Jenna L.  Thunder Bay & the First World War, 1914-1919. Thunder Bay: TBHMS, 2018.

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • No entries submitted

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Te Hiwi, Braden Paora. “Unlike their Playmates of Civilization: the Indian Children’s Recreation must be Cultivated and Developed: The Administration of Physical Education at Pelican Lake Indian Residential School, 1926-1944.” Historical Studies in Education, 29:1 (Spring 2017), 99-118.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • No entries submitted

Ernest R. Zimmermann Award: (First Publication)

  • Mastrangelo, Richard James. “Echoes and Features: Atikokan, Steep Rock Mine & Corporate Culture.” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, Papers & Records, vol 46 (2018), 29-54.

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Zimmermann, Ernest Robert. The Little Third Reich on Lake Superior: A History of Canadian Internment Camp R. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press, 2016.

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • Tarbet, David W. Grain Dust Dreams. Albany: State University of New York, 2015.

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • CO-WINNER: Luby, Brittany and Labelle, Katharine. “The New Generation: Cooperative Education at the Day School at Dalles 38C Indian Reserve, 1890-1910,” Ontario History 197:1 (Spring 2015), 88-110.
  • CO-WINNER: Warecki, George. “Environmental Coalitions and the Limits of Science: Wilderness Advocacy in Ontario in the 1970s,” Ontario History 109:1 (Spring 2017), 60-87.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Westerback, Carl H. “Tee Habour: A Memoir of a Life in a Fishing Village in the 1930s,” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, Papers & Records, vol 43 (2015), 42-56.

Ernest R. Zimmermann Award: (First Publication)

  • Tarbet, David W. Grain Dust Dreams. Albany: State University of New York, 2015.

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Beaulieu, Michel S. Labour at the Lakehead: Ethnicity, Socialism, and Politics, 1900-1935. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2011.

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • Beaulieu, Michel S. Celluloid Dreams: An Illustrated History of Early Film at the Lakehead, 1900-1931. Thunder Bay: Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, 2012.

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Soloway, Beverly. “The Fur Traders’ Garden: Horticultural Imperialism in Rupert’s Land, 1670 – 1770.” in Irish and Scots Encounters with Indigenous Peoples, edited by David A. Wilson. Montreal/Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2013.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Foulds, J.F., “How the Northern Health Travel Grant Came to Ontario: A Political Memoir,” Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, Papers & Records, vol 41 (2013), 3-24.

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • John Long, Treaty No. 9 (McGill Queens University Press, 2010)

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • James R. Stevens, Wild On The Superior Shore: A Romance Of Settlers 1850 -1900.

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Mark Kuhlberg, ”Mr. Burk is Most Interested in Their Welfare”: J.G. Burk’s Campaign to Help the Anishinabeg of NW Ontario, 1923-1953,” Journal of Canadian Studies (Winter 2010)

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Elle Andra-Warner, “In the Valley of the Slate River: A Farm Community Thrives,” in Lake Superior Magazine, (June-July 2011)

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Labour Pains, Thunder Bay’s Working Class in Canada’s Wheat Boom, by Jean Morrison (Thunder Bay: Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, 2009).

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • Dance is on Fire. By Neil McQuarrie (Fort Frances: Dance Fire Memorial Committee, 2008).

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • “A Study of the Strike at Canada Safeway by Local 175 of the UFCW,” by William Vinh-Doyle. In Essays in Northwestern Ontario Working Class History: Thunder Bay and its Environs, edited by Michel Beaulieu (Thunder Bay: Lakehead University Centre for Northern Studies, Northern and Regional Studies Series #16, 2008), 297-326.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • “A Memorial Society’s Struggle with the Funeral Industry ,” by Eleanor Dolores Dickey. In Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records XXXVI (2008), 53-67.

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Insufficient nominations

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • CO-WINNER: Aviation in Thunder Bay. By Jim Lyzun (The Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, 2007)
  • CO-WINNER: A Bit of a Legend in These Parts: The Life of Betty Berger Lessard. by Neil McQuarrie (NJM Enterprises, 2007)

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • “‘We did it just for Fun’: Amateur Filmmaking at the Lakehead, 1929-1930,” by Michel S. Beaulieu, in Ontario History XCIX:2 (Autumn 2007): 168-189.

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • “Sgt. Joe Hicks’ War,” by Bob Ingraham. In Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society Papers & Records XXXVII (2007)

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • K.C.A. Dawson, Original People and Euro Canadians in Northwestern Ontario: The Road West, the Hinge of a Developing State (Thunder Bay: Lakehead University Centre for Northern Studies, 2004)

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • Peter Raffo, 1934-2004 Lakehead Psychiatric Hospital From Institution to Community A Transformation of Psychiatric Hospital Services (Thunder Bay: St. Joseph’s Care Group, 2005)

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • Jayne Elliott, “Blurring the Boundaries of Space: Shaping Nursing Lives at the Red Cross Outposts in Ontario, 1922-1945” in Canadian Bulletin of Medical History, 21 #4 (2004), 303-25

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • Kathryn Lyzun, “Wendell Beckwith,” in TBSource, December 2-9, 2005

M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: (Academic full-length)

  • Lake Superior to Rainy Lake: Three Centuries of Fur Trade History, by Jean Morrison (published by the Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, 2003)

Gertrude H. Dyke Award: (Popular full-length)

  • Fort Frances: A Story of a Town and it’s People by Neil McQuarrie (published by the Fort Frances Museum, 2003)

J.P. Bertrand Award: (Academic Article)

  • “‘Nothing it seems can be done about it’, Charlie Cox, Indian Affairs Timber Policy, and the Long Lac Reserve, 1924-1940,” by Mark Kuhlberg (in Canadian Historical Review, vol. 84, no. 1, 2003)

George B MacGillivray Award: (Popular Article)

  • “The Great Map” by D’Arcy Jenish (in The Beaver, March 2004)

Named Award Background information

  • M. Elizabeth Arthur Award: full-length scholarly works
    • Dr. Elizabeth Arthur had a profound influence in our region. First teaching at Port Arthur Collegiate Institute and later becoming a founding member of the Department of History at Lakehead University. She well-respected historian nationally, including serving on the Council of the Champlain Society – which also published her monumental book Thunder Bay District, 1821-1892. Arthur served on the Board of the Society and, unacknowledged, steered the revived Papers & Records during the 1970s.
  • J.P. Bertrand Award: scholarly articles
    • Throughout his life, Joseph Placide Theodore Bertrand had a passion for history. Following his arrival at the Lakehead in 1900, he established himself through numerous talks, articles, and books as a leading expert on our region’s history. He was heavily involved in the Society in the 1940s and 1950s, including as board member. Bertrand’s publications include the book Highway of Destiny, perhaps the first serious analysis of the history Northwestern Ontario, and Timber Wolves, which the Society published in 1997.
  • Gertrude H. Dyke Award: full-length popular works
    • Gertrude Dyke was a prominent citizen of Port Arthur and had a great interest in local history. She published three historic booklets: “Historic Lakehead”, “Historic Silver Islet”, and “Historic Stories”.
  • George B. Macgillivray Award: popular articles
    • This award is named after long-time supporter of the Society, Colonel George B. Macgillivray. Commander of the Macgillivray Clan (1989-1994) and long-time publisher of what became the Chronicle-Journal newspaper. Macgillivray was a prolific author of articles focused on the history of our region and on Clan Macgillivray.
  • Ernest R. Zimmermann: First Publication Award
    • From his arrival to the Lakehead in 1967 to take up a position in the Department of History at Lakehead University, Dr. Ernest R Zimmermann was a force to be recognized in the region. During his career he served as chair of the Department of History (1977-1978), and as Dean of Arts (1978-1983). Ernest served on the City’s Local Architectural Conservation Authority Committee (now HAC), the executive of The Thunder Bay Historical Museum Society, and what was then known as the National Exhibition Centre for Indian Art (Thunder Bay Art Gallery). An expert on German and Russian history, his work later in life focus on the Prisoner of War Experience in Canada.
    • This award is the Society’s only cash award, paid through an endowment established by the proceeds from the book The Little Third Reich on Lake Superior: A History of Canadian Internment Camp R.
  • Innovative Media Award for the History of Northwestern Ontario
    • The Innovative Media Award for the History of Northwestern Ontario recognizes outstanding works that interpret and present the history of Northwestern Ontario through innovative or non-traditional formats.
    • Eligible works may include documentary films, podcasts, digital publications, websites, multimedia storytelling projects, graphic narratives, interactive media, or other emerging forms of public history communication. Works must demonstrate substantial historical content related to Northwestern Ontario and its communities, be publicly accessible, and be intended primarily for general audiences.
    • Submissions will be assessed for the quality and depth of historical research, sound historical analysis and interpretation, effectiveness of presentation, accessibility, audience appeal, and the appropriate use of the chosen medium.
    • Works must have been released or published within the previous three years. Self-published works and independent productions are eligible, provided they meet the award criteria.
    • Live events, temporary programming, physical exhibitions, installations, and social media campaigns are not eligible unless they have been transformed into a stable, publicly accessible, reviewable publication or media product.
    • Nominees must disclose whether artificial intelligence tools were used in the development of the work. Works are not eligible where generative artificial intelligence substantially created or replaced the human creator’s original historical interpretation or expressive content.